Is progress good? Most people would immediately answer yes. With the New York Times, however, the answer is not as clear. A recent article, “After Welcoming China’s Electric Vehicles, This Country Is Paying the Price”, by Sui-Lee Wee and Kittiphum Sringammuang, looks at what happened to the Thai car industry over the last five years:
For decades, Japanese automakers dominated Thailand. They arrived in the 1960s, built supply chains and transformed the country into the “Detroit of the East.”
Then the Chinese automakers arrived.
Today, they control about 85 percent of Thailand’s electric vehicle market, up from almost zero four years ago. Japanese automakers, slow to embrace the technology, have struggled. In 2024 and 2025, Subaru and Suzuki shut down their Thai plants, while Nissan and Honda have scaled back production.
This sounds like progress. BYD, a Chinese company and by far the world’s largest electric vehicle maker, built a massive factory in Rayong, Thailand. Great Wall Motor, a smaller Chinese EV manufacturer, took over a plant once run by General Motors. Strangely, this is being billed by the New York Times as a bad thing:
Several Thai auto-parts suppliers that depended on Japanese manufacturers went bankrupt, threatening a supply chain that employs about 700,000 workers.
“It was much faster than anything we had expected,” said Supavud Saicheua, chairman of the National Economic and Social Development Council, the central economic planning agency in Thailand.
“We didn’t think of the full picture,” he added. “The impact on Thailand has been much more adverse than we had thought.
These types of statements do not inspire confidence. It’s worrisome that the head of an economic agency would view such impacts as adverse. Economic growth relies on what economists call “creative destruction”. That is, new innovations, inventions, and technologies must replace their predecessors. What Supavud Saicheua fails to realize is that the “creative” is partially offset by the “destruction”. Any successful new company is necessarily going to put other firms out of business. Builders Square invented a better hardware store that drove dozens of local competitors into bankruptcy. Then Home Depot invented an even better hardware store that drove Builders Square into bankruptcy. Someday, another retailer might overthrow Home Depot. This is the nature of progress.
Throughout the NYT article, however, all progress is cast as a bad thing. Almost the entire piece focuses on the costs of innovation while ignoring the benefits. Far more attention is paid to the Japanese car companies and Thai suppliers that were displaced than to the gains from the new competition. Chinese companies setting up in Thailand is viewed as a “cautionary tale about the unintended consequences”. It is suggested that America and the European Union should see what happened in Thailand as a lesson in what to avoid.
What’s barely mentioned is that this isn’t even a case of foreign companies undercutting domestic businesses. It’s a case of one foreign industry (Japanese cars) being replaced by another (Chinese cars). Yet the entire article treats every job destroyed as a tragedy, while scarcely noting that the BYD factory “employs 5,600 workers, 94 percent of them Thai”. Conveniently, the size of the supply chain associated with the Chinese factories is left out altogether.
Then there’s the biggest omission of all: consumer benefits. As the article states, Japanese carmakers have been operating in Thailand for 60 years. They established a local supply chain and a loyal customer base. For them to be turfed out in such a short time span, clearly their Chinese competitors have built a better mousetrap. Yet not a single buyer is discussed. The NYT article goes to great lengths to interview a worker who was employed by an auto-supply company that shut down in 2024, possibly because of the new Chinese competition (and who won’t even apply to a Chinese company because she was told “they only hire young workers”), but doesn’t interview a single BYD owner, let alone a BYD floor employee. Only a BYD executive is quoted.
For companies like BYD to make inroads so quickly, their cars must be fantastic. And they are. The cheapest BYD electric car is sold for under $15,000. That’s a good amount of money in a middle-income country like Thailand, but far less than the price of a new Prius or Camry. This is a boon to Thai consumers.
Tourists may go to Thailand and view the thousands of scooters that many Thais use as their primary mode of transportation as charming. The reality is it’s terrifying. Thailand has the second-highest traffic-related death rate in Asia, behind only similarly scooter-loving Vietnam. Driving on Thai roads, with their mix of cars, scooters, bikes, and pedestrians, is not safe. It may look quaint when an entire family of two adults, a child, and a baby loads up onto a single scooter to run errands, but many children are killed every year in accidents. Putting cars within reach of the middle class would make Thai roads much safer.
Safety isn’t the only advantage of buying a BYD. Being electric cars, BYDs are also relatively friendly to the environment. Thailand, like most developing nations, relies on older vehicles, some of which literally belch clouds of smoke into the air. These would not pass an emissions check anywhere in the Western world and should have been consigned to the scrapheap years ago. Giving consumers a cheap electric alternative will make Thai air cleaner. This is good for the environment, and good for Thais’ health.
The article is correct that America and Europe can learn from Thailand’s approach. The lesson, however, is not one of caution, but one of adaptation. Just as Americans learned to love Japanese cars in the 1970s, given the opportunity, they will likely learn to love Chinese cars. Instead of slapping tariffs on Chinese vehicles and preventing their makers from building factories in America, the US government should welcome Chinese competition with open arms. If Americans don’t want to buy Chinese cars, they won’t. But at a time when the environment and especially affordability are the top concerns of many, having cheap electric vehicles in abundance is a slam dunk.

