Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joel's avatar

"Democracy" – it's one of those words. It never appears in the U.S. Constitution (a written constitution is a dead letter, btw), nor in the Declaration of Independence. Quite appalling to many Founding Fathers. How did this most-definitely-not-a-democracy! turn into one? When did "we" become a "democracy." And what, historically, is democracy?

From where I stand today, I'd say that 'democracy' is a kind of peasant madness, a peasant revolt against an aristocratic order, and, as such, totally reactionary. What we fail to apprehend here in the USA! USA! USA! is that the Jacobins, they were democratic; the Italian Fascists, they were democratic; the German National Socialists, they were democratic; the Russian International Socialists (Communists), they were democratic; the British Fabian Socialists, they were democratic. Europe has been living in a democratic *phase* for since at least the Frankish Genocide (sorry, "French Revolution", but how it can remain "France" when you've killed off the Frankish state is beyond me). The American (sorta-) Revolution wasn't even about the monarch – it was about established rights. That war also had its appalling democratic aspect too, just we don't talk about it, or, like the south, we're so fanatic, that we don't even care (e.g. I wanted to name my sons Grant and Sherman - gross!)

"Democracy," to us is a word, and a holy word at that. When I was in the sixth grade I realize we were being spoon-fed 'democracy,' much in the same way I had the *right* and only *true* religion: Protestantism. It's the same with 'democracy' – we have a fanatical, unquestioning and unquestionable commitment this abstraction. Well, I say it's highly questionable wether 'democracy' is good or bad for us. And it's not clear to me that a monarchy, or an aristocracy would be "bad" in any meaningful way – except for my own personal unbounded vanity, which I take to be the heart of the "Democratic Man."

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts